Tree planting on Wild Ingleborough – the story so far

Tree planting on Wild Ingleborough – the story so far

Over 150,000 trees have been planted at Wild Ingleborough to restore upland habitats and connect woodland fragments. Discover how different species and planting methods from sheltered ghylls to cattle-resistant thorny clusters are thriving against the elements. Writeen by Robyn Wrigley, Monitoring Assistant (Leeds University).

Tree planting is an important part of the restoration work at Wild Ingleborough, with the main aim of establishing seed sources in an otherwise nearly treeless landscape. Since the project began, over 150,000 trees have been planted. The planting programme also aims to link up existing woodland fragments and establish trees higher up the fells, particularly within ghylls and along watercourses.

Monitoring a subset of these planted trees helps us understand how successful the planting has been across the project, as well as how survival varies between species, planting methods and levels of browsing.

The majority of trees were planted during years 2 and 3 of the project, meaning that three-year survival results capture the progress of most of the trees currently being monitored.

Across the monitored trees, survival is 65% 3 years after planting. For trees planted 4 years ago, four-year survival is 62%. The oldest cohort, now 5 years after planting, has a five-year survival rate of 45%. However, these trees are all located at High Lot, a higher-elevation site where survival is generally lower. We might therefore expect survival at year five to be higher when more of the monitored trees reach this age. Nevertheless, these results demonstrate that, despite the challenging upland conditions at Wild Ingleborough, successful tree establishment is possible.

Three-year survival rates vary considerably between species, with hawthorn having the highest survival at 95% and holly the lowest at 33% (Figure 1). Despite this variation, 10 of the 14 tree species monitored have a three-year survival rate of 50% or above.

Bar chart showing survival rate (%) on the y-axis for different tree and shrub species listed on the x-axis, with sample size indicated for each species. Hawthorn has the highest survival rate at 95%, followed by Bird Cherry at 90%. Holly has the lowest survival rate at 33%.

Figure 1. Percentage survival of tree species three years after planting at Wild Ingleborough. Sample size for each species is shown in brackets.

We also looked at how effective different planting methods have been so far, including targeted planting within ghylls and along watercourses and densely planted, unguarded thorny clusters within cattle-grazed areas (Figure 2). 

Ghyll planting 

Trees have been planted within ghylls extending up the slopes of Ingleborough. Five species were selected for planting based on their suitability for the habitat: alder, birch, oak, rowan and willow. To date, ghyll planting appears to have been more successful than the project-wide average, with an overall three-year survival rate of 73%. Survival has been encouraging across most species, with four of the five species exceeding 70%. Oak is a notable exception, with a much lower survival rate of 27%. Although the reasons for this cannot be determined conclusively, one possible explanation is that oak experienced particularly high browsing during its first year, with 86% of oak trees browsed. This, combined with potentially lower browsing tolerance compared with the other species, may have contributed to its lower survival. This is an interesting finding that highlights how species can respond differently to the challenges of upland planting.

Thorny clusters

These clusters are predominantly hawthorn, with some blackthorn too, planted very densely in groups of around 30 trees within cattle-grazed areas. Browsing rates were high during the first 2 years, with over 90% of trees browsed. Despite this, survival was good, with 80% of trees surviving to year 2 and 78% still surviving at year 4. Browsing has also reduced substantially over this period, falling to just 4% by year 4. This suggests that the clusters have been able to withstand high initial browsing pressure and that, as the trees have grown larger and thornier, they may now be less vulnerable to browsing by cattle.

The longer-term aim is for these clusters to help encourage further natural regeneration, as well as providing a haven for wildlife. Birds may use the trees as perches, while other tree species could establish within the clusters, benefiting from some protection against browsing. Continued monitoring will help us to understand whether this additional regeneration takes place within and around the clusters, and whether they develop into valuable habitats for wildlife.